After leading more than 3,500 employee training sessions, I’ve learned a simple truth: training helps when it addresses a real skill or knowledge gap — and completely fails when it’s used to solve the wrong problem.
When clients ask me to deliver training, my first question is always the same:
“What behavior are you trying to change?”
If training will improve performance, I build the program. If it won’t, I tell them and recommend a better intervention.
When I’m subcontracted, I don’t always get the chance to diagnose the real issue before I show up. And based on those experiences, I can tell you this with confidence:
Training is often used to fix problems it has no chance of solving.
Below are the five most common situations where training is the wrong tool.
1. Employees Won’t Do the Job (Even Though They Can)
If employees aren’t performing to expectations, start with the question:
“Is this a skill problem or a will problem?”
Training works when people:
- Don’t understand the job
- Haven’t learned the required skills
But if employees do understand the work — and you’ve seen them perform it correctly before — training won’t change anything.
Common non‑training causes include:
- They don’t like the job
- They don’t feel motivated
- They don’t see why the task matters
- They don’t feel appreciated
- They don’t think the compensation is fair
- They don’t like their manager
These require leadership action, not a workshop.
2. Low Morale
When morale is low, training rarely helps and can even make things worse.
There’s one exception:
If employees feel incompetent and fear failure, training can build confidence.
But most morale issues stem from deeper causes:
- Poor leadership
- Unclear expectations
- Lack of recognition
- Workload issues
- Toxic dynamics
Training won’t fix any of these. Diagnose the root cause and address it directly.
3. Infighting and Workplace Conflict
Early in my career, I was hired to deliver a “respect” workshop for a small manufacturer. Two employees hated each other, the rest of the plant had taken sides, and everyone felt the tension.
A workshop was never going to solve that.
On the day of training, the two employees at the center of the conflict called in sick — and the rest of the group was understandably irritated about being forced into a session that didn’t address the real issue.
When conflict is interpersonal and specific, the solution is:
- Mediation
- Coaching
- Clear expectations
- Consequences
And if people refuse to resolve the conflict, replacing one or both may be necessary.
Don’t schedule a training session.
4. Lack of Ability (Not Lack of Training)
Some performance gaps aren’t about skills — they’re about natural ability.
No amount of training will turn me into an NBA player.
And no workshop will turn:
- A deeply introverted person into a natural schmoozer
- A big‑picture thinker into a meticulous detail‑tracker
If the job requires abilities someone simply doesn’t have, you have a job‑fit problem, not a training problem.
The options are:
- Change the job
- Or change the person in the job
Training won’t fix this mismatch.
5. Inadequate Resources or Broken Systems
When employees don’t have:
- Enough team members
- Functional equipment
- Clear processes
- Reasonable workloads
…performance will suffer.
And yet, organizations often respond by sending people to training.
Training cannot fix:
- Understaffing
- Outdated tools
- Inefficient workflows
- Systemic bottlenecks
Fix the system first.
Then, if skills are still a barrier, consider training.
If Training Isn’t the Answer, What Is?
The right intervention depends on the situation. Alternatives include:
- Improving processes
- Clarifying expectations
- Fixing broken systems
- Adjusting staffing levels
- Providing better tools
- Using progressive discipline
- Addressing incentives
- Resolving conflict
- Reassigning or replacing employees
I enjoy delivering workshops — but I enjoy solving real problems even more. That requires diagnosing the issue accurately and choosing the intervention that will actually change the situation.
Training is one option. It just isn’t the right option for every problem.
Author
Tom LaForce
Tom LaForce is a Minnesota-based consultant, speaker, coach, and facilitator. He provides practical, people‑focused support that helps organizations make change, reduce conflict, and create better workplaces. He’s available for fractional and project-based assignment. Reach out to discuss your goals.






